The purpose of this edifice of security is to be found in the fact that Dafydd had a formidable rival. Gruffydd (q.v.) was an elder son of Llywelyn and, though born out of wedlock, was not for this reason debarred by Welsh law from the succession. He was popular and had the advantage of a mother with Welsh connections. His father was not unwilling to provide for him, but, as Llywelyn grew older and Dafydd took the reins, less room was allowed for his activities. On 19 Oct. 1238 all the lesser princes of Wales swore fealty at Strata Florida to the designated heir, who forthwith deprived Gruffydd of his extensive holding in southern Powys and reduced him to the cantref of Llŷn . Next year there was a colloquy between the supporters of the two brothers; Dafydd took a treacherous advantage of the occasion to seize Gruffydd and his son Owain , who were imprisoned in Cricieth castle .
Thus, when Llywelyn died on 11 April 1240 there was no obstacle to the succession of Dafydd . He had the powerful support of the late prince's chief counsellor , Ednyfed Fychan (q.v.) , of Einon Fychan , one of Llywelyn 's regular envoys, and of the bishop of S. Asaph . On 15 May , at a great assembly at Gloucester , the king met his nephew, knighted him, received his homage for Gwynedd , and set on his head the ‘talaith,’ or diadem, which was the token of princely dignity. But this did not entitle him to hold the outlying lands which his father had acquired during his victorious career. Their destination, it was declared, was to be settled by arbitration.
Loth to lose anything he could retain, Dafydd now resorted to delaying tactics, until, in the summer of 1241 , Henry could wait no longer and led an expedition into North Wales . His progress was unexpectedly easy; an abnormal drought removed many of the usual obstacles, and the prince was forced to agree, at Gwern Eigron , near S. Asaph , on 29 Aug. , to a peace which required him to resign all claim to the territories in dispute, to surrender his prisoners, Gruffydd and Owain , and also to give up Ellesmere , Tegeingl , and further, when the peace was confirmed in London in Oct., the stronghold of Degannwy .
The position now was that while the king had no desire to oppose Gruffydd to Dafydd he could do so when he pleased — an excellent guarantee for the good behaviour of his nephew. Peace was thus maintained, until an untoward incident on 1 March 1244 radically altered the situation. Gruffydd broke his neck in seeking to escape from the Tower . At once Dafydd was freed from his anxieties and began to reopen the conflict. He won the support of nearly all the Welsh princes ( Powys , as usual, standing aloof), and was emboldened to submit his case, with some success, to Innocent IV , pleading that his parents had placed him under the special protection of the Holy See . Henry was slow to take up the challenge, misled, it may be, by the easy victory of 1241 . But, as it became evident that the Welsh were making headway, recapturing Mold , for instance, in the spring of 1245 , he was stirred into action and appeared at Degannwy with a large force in the late summer of that year. Dafydd and his men offered a vigorous and successful resistance, so that in a couple of months the royal host had to withdraw, with little to show for their pains. The issue was still in doubt when, on 25 Feb. 1246 , it was suddenly determined by the death of the prince at his manor of Aber . He was buried with his father and brother in the abbey of Aberconwy , and, as he left no child, the structure set up by Llywelyn collapsed and the triumph of the Crown was complete. His widow returned to England ; she was allotted Haverford later, out of her mother's portion of the great Marshal inheritance, but did not long enjoy it, for by Feb. 1248 she was dead.
Sir John Edward Lloyd, D.Litt., F.B.A., F.S.A. (1861-1947), Bangor
Published date: 1959